The Holidays Aren’t Always Merry: How to Protect Your Mental Health, Set Boundaries, and Tell the Truth This Season

The holiday season arrives with an unspoken script that most of us learn early.]

Family togetherness.

Joy. Gratitude.

Tradition. Celebration.

It is presented as universal, unquestionable, and emotionally mandatory.

For some people, that script fits. The holidays bring warmth, laughter, and a sense of belonging that feels genuine and nourishing.

But for many others, the holidays are complicated. Heavy. Emotionally loaded. They stir grief, tension, shame, resentment, and exhaustion that has nothing to do with decorations or gift lists and everything to do with history.

That reality deserves honesty.

As a family physician, a wellness and leadership coach, and a human who has lived through seasons of burnout, recovery, growth, and recalibration, I want to name what many people quietly carry:

Not all families are healthy.

Not all traditions are safe.

And not all holiday gatherings deserve unquestioned loyalty.

Acknowledging that truth does not make you ungrateful or broken.

It makes you self-aware.

Why the Holidays Trigger Emotional Stress and Mental Health Strain

The holidays do not create emotional strain. They amplify what already exists.

If your relationships are supportive and secure, this season can feel grounding and connective.

If they are strained, unresolved, or emotionally unsafe, the holidays magnify every fault line.

Old family roles reappear without warning. The “peacemaker,” the “responsible one,” the “problem child,” the one who swallows discomfort so others can feel comfortable. Longstanding dynamics often snap back into place the moment people gather under one roof.

Expectations increase at the same time resilience is depleted.

From a mental health and nervous system perspective, this is predictable. During the holidays, people experience:

• Disrupted routines and sleep

• Increased social pressure

• Financial stress

• Heightened emotional labor

• Increased alcohol consumption

• Less physical movement and downtime

The nervous system reads all of this as threat and overload.

And yet, many people feel guilty for struggling, as though discomfort during the holidays is a moral failure rather than a human response.

Let me be very clear:

Feeling overwhelmed during the holidays is not a personal weakness.

It is often a sign that you are paying attention to your emotional reality.

Guilt Is Not the Same as Love

One of the most important social and emotional learning lessons we can develop, at any age, is learning to separate guilt from responsibility.

Guilt often shows up when we disrupt old patterns.

It appears when you:

• Set boundaries

• Say no

• Shorten visits

• Create distance

• Stop absorbing discomfort on behalf of others

Guilt often follows, especially if your role has historically been to accommodate at your own expense.

That guilt does not mean you are wrong.

It often means you are growing.

Healthy relationships do not require self-abandonment.

Love does not demand emotional erasure.

If someone’s comfort depends on your silence, exhaustion, or compliance, that is not connection. That is a pattern in need of examination.

Decide in Advance: How Long You’ll Stay and Where You’ll Stay

One of the most effective tools for emotional regulation during the holidays is pre-decision.

Decide ahead of time:

• How long you will stay

• Where you will stay

• What behavior you will and will not tolerate

Many adults forget this simple truth: we have choices.

You are allowed to choose:

• A hotel instead of your childhood home

• A short visit instead of an extended stay

• Neutral ground instead of emotionally loaded spaces

These decisions are not cold or punitive. They are strategic and protective.

You might say:

• “I’ll come for dinner, but I won’t stay overnight.”

• “I’m staying elsewhere so I can show up regulated.”

• “I’m limiting my visit to two days this year.”

From a social and emotional learning standpoint, this reflects self-awareness paired with responsible decision-making. You are not rejecting people. You are managing yourself.

And that distinction matters.

Sometimes the Healthiest Choice Is Saying No

There are seasons when the most emotionally mature choice is to decline altogether.

No long explanations.

No defending your mental health.

No negotiating your boundaries.

Saying no may bring backlash. You may be met with guilt, pressure, or emotional manipulation.

That reaction often says more about unresolved dynamics than it does about your choice.

You are not responsible for regulating the emotions of other adults.

You are responsible for your own well-being.

Learning to tolerate discomfort, both yours and theirs, is a core skill of emotional resilience.

The Hardest Truth: Sometimes We Are Part of the Work

This is the part many articles avoid, but real healing demands it.

Sometimes strained relationships are not only about the toxicity of others.

Sometimes they also reflect our own behaviors, blind spots, or unhealed patterns.

That reality does not require shame. It requires courage.

True emotional intelligence includes:

• Accountability

• Self-reflection

• Willingness to repair

• Emotional honesty

Questions worth asking include:

• What patterns do I perpetuate?

• Where do I avoid difficult conversations?

• What parts of me still need healing before reconciliation is possible?

Avoidance keeps cycles intact.

Honesty, even when uncomfortable, creates the possibility for change.

Truth Is Not Cruel — It’s Clarifying

Many people fear that telling the truth will cause harm.

In reality, it is often silence and suppression that do the most damage.

Truth, when spoken with integrity and care, clarifies. It brings alignment between what we feel and how we live. It creates the conditions for real healing, whether that leads to deeper connection, redefined relationships, or respectful distance.

There is no genuine healing without truth.

The holidays do not manufacture these issues. They reveal them.

If You’re Spending the Holidays Alone, You Are Not Failing

There is another assumption worth dismantling: that being alone during the holidays is inherently sad.

It isn’t.

Solitude can be restorative.

It can be peaceful.

It can be safer than forcing connection where there is none.

Loneliness is about emotional disconnection, not proximity.

Choosing peace over performance is not avoidance. It is discernment.

A Grounded Closing Thought

If this season feels heavy, let this land gently:

You are allowed to protect your mental health.

You are allowed to choose differently.

You are allowed to evolve beyond traditions that no longer fit the person you have become.

And if the only thing you manage this holiday season is keeping your nervous system intact, showing yourself compassion, and honoring your limits?

That is not failure.

That is strength.

Disclaimer

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. It is not intended to diagnose, treat, or cure any condition. Always seek guidance from a qualified healthcare provider about your health.

View our privacy policy here. 

© 2025 Dr. Tomi Mitchell / Holistic Wellness Strategies. All rights reserved.

This document and its contents are the intellectual property of Dr. Tomi Mitchell / Holistic Wellness Strategies and may not be copied, reproduced, or distributed in any form without express written consent.